Motorists Mutual Insurance Company

Florida
Registered In
09/24/1979
Incorp. Date
Foreign
Registration Type
Ohio
Foreign Jurisdiction

Company Summary

Motorists Mutual Insurance Company at 471 E Broad St, Columbus, Oh 43215 lists Cooper, John L. of Columbus, OH and Wharton, Garry L. of Westerville, OH.

Overview

Registered In
Florida
Incorporation Date
Company Type
Foreign Profit
Status
Inactive
Registration Type
Foreign
Foreign Jurisdiction
Ohio
EIN
31-4259550
Find Social Profiles
Search Other Resources

People

Chief Financial Officer Registered Agent
P O BOX 6200 (32314-6200), TALLAHASSEE, FL 32399
Cooper, John L. Director
1760 ROCKY PINE LOOP N, COLUMBUS, OH
Wharton, Garry L. Director
248 APACHE CIR, WESTERVILLE, OH
Wright, Lloyd G. CPD
775 CHAFFIN RDG, COLUMBUS, OH
Rabold, Robert EVD
4036 OVERLOOK DR E, COLUMBUS, OH
Keltner, J.R. Secretary/Director
314 W NEW ENGLAND AVE, WORTHINGTON, OH
Greathouse, Richard C. Treasurer/Director
3145 RIVERMILL DR, COLUMBUS, OH

Map & Locations

471 E BROAD ST, COLUMBUS, OH 43215 View Map

Financials

Financial Information for Motorists Mutual Insurance Company

Form 5500

MOTORISTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY

471 E. Broad Street, Columbus, Oh 43215 (304) 941-1000 EIN:31-4259550 Plan Admin:Kimberli Lanham
Year Plan Name Participants BOY/EOY Assets BOY/EOY
2022 Plan NameENCOVA INSURANCE 401(K) PLAN Plan #003 Participants BOY/EOY1,651 / 1,659 Assets BOY/EOY$316,087,508 / $256,107,467 2022 ENCOVA INSURANCE 401(K) PLAN - Plan #003 1,651 / 1,659 $316,087,508 / $256,107,467
2022 Plan NameMOTORISTS MUTUAL RETIREMENT PLAN Plan #001 Participants BOY/EOY356 / 358 Assets BOY/EOY$91,475,930 / $67,633,023 2022 MOTORISTS MUTUAL RETIREMENT PLAN - Plan #001 356 / 358 $91,475,930 / $67,633,023
2022 Plan NameENCOVA INSURANCE RETIREE BENEFITS PLAN Plan #503 Participants BOY/EOY256 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2022 ENCOVA INSURANCE RETIREE BENEFITS PLAN - Plan #503 256 / 0 $0 / $0
2022 Plan NameENCOVA INSURANCE HEALTH AND WELFARE BENEFITS PLAN Plan #502 Participants BOY/EOY975 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2022 ENCOVA INSURANCE HEALTH AND WELFARE BENEFITS PLAN - Plan #502 975 / 0 $0 / $0
2021 Plan NameENCOVA INSURANCE 401(K) PLAN Plan #003 Participants BOY/EOY1,827 / 1,651 Assets BOY/EOY$283,032,723 / $316,087,508 2021 ENCOVA INSURANCE 401(K) PLAN - Plan #003 1,827 / 1,651 $283,032,723 / $316,087,508
2021 Plan NameMOTORISTS MUTUAL RETIREMENT PLAN Plan #001 Participants BOY/EOY363 / 356 Assets BOY/EOY$88,885,078 / $91,475,930 2021 MOTORISTS MUTUAL RETIREMENT PLAN - Plan #001 363 / 356 $88,885,078 / $91,475,930
2021 Plan NameENCOVA INSURANCE HEALTH AND WELFARE BENEFITS PLAN Plan #502 Participants BOY/EOY967 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2021 ENCOVA INSURANCE HEALTH AND WELFARE BENEFITS PLAN - Plan #502 967 / 0 $0 / $0
2021 Plan NameENCOVA INSURANCE RETIREE BENEFITS PLAN Plan #503 Participants BOY/EOY289 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2021 ENCOVA INSURANCE RETIREE BENEFITS PLAN - Plan #503 289 / 0 $0 / $0
2020 Plan NameENCOVA INSURANCE 401(K) PLAN Plan #003 Participants BOY/EOY1,700 / 1,822 Assets BOY/EOY$236,715,921 / $283,032,723 2020 ENCOVA INSURANCE 401(K) PLAN - Plan #003 1,700 / 1,822 $236,715,921 / $283,032,723
2020 Plan NameMOTORISTS MUTUAL RETIREMENT PLAN Plan #001 Participants BOY/EOY371 / 363 Assets BOY/EOY$79,360,437 / $88,885,078 2020 MOTORISTS MUTUAL RETIREMENT PLAN - Plan #001 371 / 363 $79,360,437 / $88,885,078
2020 Plan NameENCOVA INSURANCE HEALTH AND WELFARE BENEFITS PLAN Plan #502 Participants BOY/EOY1,005 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2020 ENCOVA INSURANCE HEALTH AND WELFARE BENEFITS PLAN - Plan #502 1,005 / 0 $0 / $0
2020 Plan NameENCOVA INSURANCE RETIREE BENEFITS PLAN Plan #503 Participants BOY/EOY329 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2020 ENCOVA INSURANCE RETIREE BENEFITS PLAN - Plan #503 329 / 0 $0 / $0
2019 Plan NameMOTORISTS INSURANCE GROUP 401(K) PLAN Plan #003 Participants BOY/EOY1,752 / 1,700 Assets BOY/EOY$190,854,455 / $236,715,921 2019 MOTORISTS INSURANCE GROUP 401(K) PLAN - Plan #003 1,752 / 1,700 $190,854,455 / $236,715,921
2019 Plan NameMOTORISTS MUTUAL RETIREMENT PLAN Plan #001 Participants BOY/EOY405 / 371 Assets BOY/EOY$68,912,407 / $79,360,437 2019 MOTORISTS MUTUAL RETIREMENT PLAN - Plan #001 405 / 371 $68,912,407 / $79,360,437
2019 Plan NameMOTORISTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY GROUP HEALTH AND WELFARE BENEFITS PLAN Plan #502 Participants BOY/EOY1,149 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2019 MOTORISTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY GROUP HEALTH AND WELFARE BENEFITS PLAN - Plan #502 1,149 / 0 $0 / $0
Benefit & Retirement Plans based on Form 5500.

Linked Companies

Address Match:471 E Broad St Columbus, OH
American Hardware Mutual Insurance Company Registered in West Virginia
Columbus, OH View Report
Broad Street Brokerage Insurance Agency, LLC Registered in West Virginia
Charleston, WV Columbus, OH View Report
Encova Insurance Agency, Inc. Registered in West Virginia
Charleston, WV Columbus, OH View Report
Encova Service Corporation Registered in West Virginia
Charleston, WV Columbus, OH View Report
Mico Insurance Company Registered in West Virginia
Columbus, OH View Report
Motorists Commercial Mutual Insurance Company Registered in West Virginia
Columbus, OH View Report
Motorists Life Insurance Company Registered in West Virginia
Columbus, OH View Report
Columbus, OH View Report
Broad Street Brokerage Insurance Agency, LLC Registered in Massachusetts
Boston, MA Columbus, OH View Report
Consumers Insurance Usa, Inc. Registered in Virginia
Columbus, OH View Report
Encova Insurance Agency, Inc. Registered in North Dakota
Bismarck, ND Columbus, OH View Report
Encova Insurance Agency, Inc. Registered in Vermont
Barre, VT Columbus, OH View Report
Encova Life Insurance Company Registered in Florida
Columbus, OH Tallahassee, FL View Report
Columbus, OH Richmond, VA View Report
Charleston, WV Columbus, OH View Report
Encova Insurance Agency, Inc. Registered in Idaho
Columbus, OH View Report
Encova Insurance Agency, Inc. Registered in Montana
Columbus, OH Helena, MT View Report
Encova Service Corporation Registered in North Carolina
Columbus, OH Raleigh, NC View Report
Sp Driving Solutions, LLC. Registered in Ohio
Columbus, OH View Report
Encova Insurance Agency, Inc. Registered in Alabama
Columbus, OH Montgomery, AL View Report
Broad Street Brokerage Insurance Agency, LLC Registered in New Hampshire
Columbus, OH Concord, NH View Report
Encova Life Insurance Company Registered in Missouri
Columbus, OH View Report
Encova Service Corporation Registered in New Hampshire
Columbus, OH View Report
Encova Service Corporation Registered in Oklahoma
Columbus, OH Oklahoma City, OK View Report
Columbus, OH View Report
Consumers Insurance Group, Inc. Registered in Tennessee
Columbus, OH Nashville, TN View Report
Consumers Insurance Usa, Inc. Registered in Tennessee
Columbus, OH Nashville, TN View Report
Encova Insurance Agency, Inc. Registered in North Dakota
Bismarck, ND Columbus, OH View Report
Mcm Insurance Agency, Inc. Registered in North Dakota
Bismarck, ND Columbus, OH View Report
Encova Insurance Agency, Inc. Registered in New Hampshire
Columbus, OH View Report
Phenix Mutual Fire Insurance Company Registered in New Hampshire
Columbus, OH Concord, NH View Report
Ahm Insurance Agency, Inc. Registered in California
Columbus, OH Fresno, CA View Report
Columbus, OH Fresno, CA View Report
Related Business Names:
Motorists Mutual Insurance Company Registered in West Virginia
Charleston, WV Columbus, OH View Report
Motorists Mutual Insurance Company Registered in West Virginia
Circleville, OH Columbus, OH View Report
Upper Arlington, OH Columbus, OH View Report
Upper Arlington, OH Columbus, OH View Report
Columbus, OH View Report
Columbus, OH View Report
Columbus, OH Jefferson City, MO (1 more) View Report
Columbus, OH Littleton, CO View Report
Motorists Mutual Insurance Company Registered in Virginia
Virginia View Report
Person/City Match:Chief Financial Officer - Tallahassee, FL
General Reinsurance Corporation Registered in Florida
Stamford, CT View Report
Massachusetts Bay Insurance Company Registered in Florida
Worcester, MA View Report
Protect My Car Admin Services Inc. Registered in Florida
Saint Petersburg, FL View Report
Greenwood, IN Indianapolis, IN View Report
American Travelers Assurance Company Registered in Florida
Norwalk, CT View Report
Arizona Premium Finance Co., Inc. Registered in Florida
Phoenix, AZ Tallahassee, FL View Report
C.P.A. Insurance Company Registered in Florida
Charter Township of West Bloomfield, MI Laguna Beach, CA View Report
Cedar Hill Assurance Company Registered in Florida
Scottsdale, AZ Tallahassee, FL View Report
Cnr Health, Inc. Registered in Florida
Tallahassee, FL Waukesha, WI View Report
Kansas City, MO Tallahassee, FL View Report
Miami, FL View Report
Jacksonville, FL Montgomery, AL View Report
Saint Petersburg, FL View Report
Harleysville, PA View Report
International Life Insurance Company Registered in Florida
Louisville, KY View Report
Louisville Title Insurance Company Registered in Florida
Louisville, KY View Report
National Automotive Rpg, LLC Registered in Florida
Overland Park, KS Tallahassee, FL View Report
National Bail and Surety Company Registered in Florida
Louisville, KY Miami, FL View Report
St. Johns Insurance Company, Inc. Registered in Florida
Orlando, FL Tallahassee, FL View Report
Wfg National Title Insurance Company Registered in Florida
Portland, OR View Report
Person/City Match:Cooper John L - Columbus, OH
Mileasing Company Registered in West Virginia
Charleston, WV Columbus, OH View Report
Person/City Match:Wharton Garry L - Westerville, OH
Ideation, Incorporated Registered in Ohio
Ohio View Report
Ohio View Report
Person/City Match:Wright Lloyd G - Columbus, OH
Encova Service Corporation Registered in Ohio
Upper Arlington, OH Columbus, OH View Report
Mico Insurance Company Registered in Ohio
Upper Arlington, OH Columbus, OH View Report
Mileasing Company Registered in Pennsylvania
Columbus, OH View Report
Motorists Premium Finance Company Registered in Pennsylvania
Columbus, OH View Report
Ohio View Report
Mileasing Company Registered in Ohio
Ohio View Report
Motorists Agency Services, Inc. Registered in Ohio
Columbus, OH View Report
Motorists Building Corporation Registered in Ohio
Columbus, OH View Report
Ohio View Report
Person/City Match:Rabold Robert - Columbus, OH
Columbus, OH View Report

Sources

The following government agencies have contributed data:

• Florida Department of State • U.S. Department of Labor
Have questions?
You can easily find answers to common questions on the Frequently Asked Questions page.
IncTrace, LLC is not a consumer reporting agency as defined by the Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 USC § 1681 et seq, (“FCRA”). We prohibit the use of this website or any information derived from it to make any determinations regarding employment, consumer credit, insurance, tenant screening, or any other purpose that would require FCRA compliance.
© 2025 IncTrace, LLC
Delaware, United States