Logo Logo
Log In

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

New Berlin, NY
Florida
Registered In
09/22/1955
Incorp. Date
Foreign
Registration Type
New York
Foreign Jurisdiction

Company Summary

Preferred Mutual Insurance Company at One Preferred Way, New Berlin, Ny 13411 lists Craine, William C. of Sherburne, NY and Cooney, Matthew T. of Norwich, NY.

Overview

Registered In
Florida
Incorporation Date
Company Type
Foreign Profit
Status
Inactive
Registration Type
Foreign
Foreign Jurisdiction
New York
EIN
15-0420080
Find Social Profiles
Search Other Resources
SEC | EDGAR Sunbiz Trellis.Law Recent News

People

Massie James Registered Agent
315 S CALHOUN ST, TALLAHASSEE, FL 32301
Craine, William C. Director
53 CHENANGO ST, SHERBURNE, NY
Cooney, Matthew T. Director
40 RANDALL AVE, NORWICH, NY
Wadsworth Robert A President/CEO
7 NEW BERLIN HTS, NEW BERLIN, NY 13411
Woodard Lynn AVP
684 COYE BROOK RD, SOUTH NEW BERLIN, NY 13843
Taft Christopher P SVPC
188 ARROWHEAD WAY, CLINTON, NY 13323
Digiuseppe N P SVPC
12 CUSHMAN ST, NEW BERLIN, NY 13411

Map & Locations

ONE PREFERRED WAY, NEW BERLIN, NY 13411 View Map

Financials

Financial Information for Preferred Mutual Insurance Company

Form 5500

PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY

One Preferred Way, New Berlin, Ny 13411 (607) 847-6161 EIN:15-0420080 Plan Admin:Pauline Ashworth
Year Plan Name Participants BOY/EOY Assets BOY/EOY
2023 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS Plan #512 Participants BOY/EOY230 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2023 PREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS - Plan #512 230 / 0 $0 / $0
2023 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY Plan #509 Participants BOY/EOY287 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2023 PREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY - Plan #509 287 / 0 $0 / $0
2023 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN Plan #508 Participants BOY/EOY249 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2023 PREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN - Plan #508 249 / 0 $0 / $0
2023 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM Plan #516 Participants BOY/EOY371 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2023 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM - Plan #516 371 / 0 $0 / $0
2022 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN Plan #001 Participants BOY/EOY461 / 469 Assets BOY/EOY$54,991,113 / $44,927,100 2022 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN - Plan #001 461 / 469 $54,991,113 / $44,927,100
2022 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY EMPLOYEES' CASH AND DEFERRED SAVINGS PROFIT SHARING PLAN Plan #003 Participants BOY/EOY388 / 388 Assets BOY/EOY$49,620,832 / $39,282,889 2022 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY EMPLOYEES' CASH AND DEFERRED SAVINGS PROFIT SHARING PLAN - Plan #003 388 / 388 $49,620,832 / $39,282,889
2022 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY Plan #509 Participants BOY/EOY278 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2022 PREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY - Plan #509 278 / 0 $0 / $0
2022 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS Plan #512 Participants BOY/EOY224 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2022 PREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS - Plan #512 224 / 0 $0 / $0
2022 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM Plan #516 Participants BOY/EOY360 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2022 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM - Plan #516 360 / 0 $0 / $0
2022 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN Plan #508 Participants BOY/EOY240 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2022 PREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN - Plan #508 240 / 0 $0 / $0
2021 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN Plan #001 Participants BOY/EOY470 / 461 Assets BOY/EOY$49,028,017 / $54,991,113 2021 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN - Plan #001 470 / 461 $49,028,017 / $54,991,113
2021 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE CO. EMPLOYEES' CASH AND DEFERRED SAVINGS PROFIT SHARING PLAN Plan #003 Participants BOY/EOY403 / 388 Assets BOY/EOY$42,349,333 / $49,620,832 2021 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE CO. EMPLOYEES' CASH AND DEFERRED SAVINGS PROFIT SHARING PLAN - Plan #003 403 / 388 $42,349,333 / $49,620,832
2021 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM Plan #516 Participants BOY/EOY379 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2021 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM - Plan #516 379 / 0 $0 / $0
2021 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY Plan #509 Participants BOY/EOY288 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2021 PREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY - Plan #509 288 / 0 $0 / $0
2021 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS Plan #512 Participants BOY/EOY250 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2021 PREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS - Plan #512 250 / 0 $0 / $0
2021 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN Plan #508 Participants BOY/EOY254 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2021 PREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN - Plan #508 254 / 0 $0 / $0
2020 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN Plan #001 Participants BOY/EOY444 / 449 Assets BOY/EOY$45,614,224 / $49,028,017 2020 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN - Plan #001 444 / 449 $45,614,224 / $49,028,017
2020 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE CO. EMPLOYEES' CASH AND DEFERRED SAVINGS PROFIT SHARING PLAN Plan #003 Participants BOY/EOY398 / 399 Assets BOY/EOY$36,543,367 / $42,349,333 2020 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE CO. EMPLOYEES' CASH AND DEFERRED SAVINGS PROFIT SHARING PLAN - Plan #003 398 / 399 $36,543,367 / $42,349,333
2020 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN Plan #508 Participants BOY/EOY246 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2020 PREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN - Plan #508 246 / 0 $0 / $0
2020 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM Plan #516 Participants BOY/EOY373 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2020 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM - Plan #516 373 / 0 $0 / $0
2020 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS Plan #512 Participants BOY/EOY238 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2020 PREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS - Plan #512 238 / 0 $0 / $0
2020 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY Plan #509 Participants BOY/EOY280 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2020 PREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY - Plan #509 280 / 0 $0 / $0
2019 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN Plan #001 Participants BOY/EOY447 / 424 Assets BOY/EOY$38,201,886 / $45,614,224 2019 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY RETIREMENT BENEFIT ACCUMULATION PLAN - Plan #001 447 / 424 $38,201,886 / $45,614,224
2019 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE CO. EMPLOYEES' CASH AND DEFERRED SAVINGS PROFIT SHARING PLAN Plan #003 Participants BOY/EOY379 / 393 Assets BOY/EOY$31,011,992 / $36,543,367 2019 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE CO. EMPLOYEES' CASH AND DEFERRED SAVINGS PROFIT SHARING PLAN - Plan #003 379 / 393 $31,011,992 / $36,543,367
2019 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM Plan #516 Participants BOY/EOY355 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2019 PREFERRED MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIFE INSURANCE PROGRAM - Plan #516 355 / 0 $0 / $0
2019 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY Plan #509 Participants BOY/EOY236 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2019 PREFERRED MUTUAL LONG TERM DISABILITY - Plan #509 236 / 0 $0 / $0
2019 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS Plan #512 Participants BOY/EOY237 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2019 PREFERRED MUTUAL MEDICAL BENEFITS - Plan #512 237 / 0 $0 / $0
2019 Plan NamePREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN Plan #508 Participants BOY/EOY237 / 0 Assets BOY/EOY$0 / $0 2019 PREFERRED MUTUAL DENTAL & VISION PLAN - Plan #508 237 / 0 $0 / $0
Benefit & Retirement Plans based on Form 5500.

Linked Companies

Related Business Names:
Preferred Risk Mutual Insurance Company Registered in West Virginia
Des Moines, IA View Report
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company Registered in Colorado
Denver, CO View Report
Midwest Preferred Mutual Insurance Company Registered in Missouri
Tina, MO View Report
Preferred Standard Mutual Insurance Company Registered in Missouri
O'fallon, MO Saint Louis, MO View Report
Florida Preferred Mutual Insurance Company Registered in Florida
Sarasota, FL View Report
Preferred Mutual Insurance Company Registered in Virginia
Virginia View Report
Preferred Risk Mutual Insurance Company Registered in Tennessee
Nashville, TN View Report
Person/City Match:Massie James - Tallahassee, FL
Canopy Oaks Farm, Inc. Registered in Florida
Tallahassee, FL View Report
Coastal Charters, Inc. Registered in Florida
Tallahassee, FL View Report
Coastal Yacht Brokers, Inc. Registered in Florida
Tallahassee, FL View Report
Florida Maritime Services Corporation Registered in Florida
Tallahassee, FL View Report
Seaport Training and Employment Program, Inc. Registered in Florida
Tallahassee, FL View Report
Seaport Training and Employment Program, Inc. Registered in Florida
Tallahassee, FL View Report
Person/City Match:Craine William C - Sherburne, NY
Granite Capital Holdings, Inc. Registered in Florida
Norwich, NY Sidney, NY View Report
View More in New Berlin, NY

Sources

The following government agencies have contributed data:

• Florida Department of State • U.S. Department of Labor
Manage Profile Opt-Out
Have questions?
You can easily find answers to common questions on the Frequently Asked Questions page.
IncTrace, LLC is not a consumer reporting agency as defined by the Fair Credit Reporting Act, 15 USC § 1681 et seq, (“FCRA”). We prohibit the use of this website or any information derived from it to make any determinations regarding employment, consumer credit, insurance, tenant screening, or any other purpose that would require FCRA compliance.

Quick Nav

Home Search Browse by Location API FAQ Contact Us

Sign Up/Log In

Sign Up Log In
© 2026 IncTrace, LLC
Delaware, United States